This Week in Scams: Fake Steaks and Debit Card Porch Pirates

McAfee

Nov 07, 2025

7 MIN READ

We’re back with a new edition of “This Week in Scams,” a roundup of what’s current and trending in all things sketchy online.

This week, we have fake steaks, why you should shop online with a credit card, and a new and utterly brash form of debit card fraud.

Fake steaks from “0maha Steaks”

Yes, the letter “O” for Omaha in the subject line of this email scam is actually a zero. And that’s not the only thing that’s off with this email, it’s a total scam.

If you like your choice cuts, the name Omaha Steaks might be a familiar one. They’ve been around for almost 110 years, and since 1953 they’ve been in the mail order meat business. Today, they sell, well, just about anything you can picture in the butcher or seafood case. With that, the company enjoys a premium reputation, so it’s little surprise scammers have latched onto it and built a phishing attack around the brand—one they garnish with a nod to concerns over rising food prices.

A few things can quickly tip you off to this scam. For starters, the scammers oddly spell Omaha with a zero in the subject line, as mentioned. From there, the sender’s email address is a straight ref flag. In this case, it’s the curiously spelled “steaksamplnext” followed by a (redacted) domain name that isn’t the legitimate omahasteaks dot-com address. Also curious is the lack of an actual price for the bogus “Gourmet Box.” And lastly, you might think that a premium foods brand would showcase some pictures of their famous fare in the email. Not so here.

Rounding it out, you’ll see the classic scammer tactics of scarcity and urgency, which scammers hope will pressure people to act immediately. In this case, only 500 of these supposed boxes are available, and the offer “concludes tomorrow.”

How to avoid Omaha Steak scams and phishing scams like them

Even as this scam makes the rounds, it’s easy to spot if you give it a closer look and a little thought—giving it a sort of old-school feel to it. However, more and more of today’s phishing emails look increasingly legit, thanks to AI tools, which might get you to click.

As for phishing attacks like this in general, you can protect yourself by:

Always checking the email address of the sender. If it doesn’t match the proper address of the company or brand that’s supposedly sending the email, it’s a scam. In this case, from the people at Omaha Steaks themselves, “If it doesn’t show OmahaSteaks.com and @OmahaSteaks, it’s not us!”

Looking for addresses and links that look like they’ve been slightly altered so that they seem “close enough” to the real thing. In this case, the scammer didn’t even bother to try. However, you could expect an alteration like “omahasteakofferforyou.com” to try and look legit.

Getting a scam detector. Our Scam Detector, found in all core McAfee plans, helps you stay safer with advanced scam detection technology built to spot and stop scams across text messages, emails, and videos. It’ll also block those sites if you accidentally tap or click on a bad link.

One good reason for using your credit card when shopping online.

What’s the most common kind of fraud? If you said, “credit card,” you’ll find it number five on the list. The top form is debit cards, according to 2025 findings from the U.S. Federal Reserve.

As reported by financial institutions, the Fed found that attempts at debit card fraud rose to 73% with 52% of those attempts being successful.

There’s a good reason for that debit card fraud ranks highest for attempts and success rate. It’s the same reason that credit card fraud is relatively low. Debit cards don’t have the same fraud protections in place that credit cards do.

As you might have read in our blogs before, credit cards offer additional protection thanks to the Fair Credit Billing Act (FCBA). Your maximum liability is $50 for fraudulent charges on a lost or stolen card if you report the loss to your issuer within 60 days. In the case of relatively unprotected debit cards, those losses often go unrecovered.

Keep this in mind as you sit down for your online shopping for the holidays: use a credit card instead of a debit card. That gives you the protection of the FCBA if your shopping session gets hacked or if the retailer experiences a data breach somewhere down the road. Also think about making it even safer by shopping with a VPN. Our VPN creates an encrypted “tunnel” that protects your data from crooks and prying eyes, so your card info stays private.

A new debit card scam with a porch pirate twist

First reported by the FBI last year, we’re seeing continued reports of a brash and bold form of debit card scam—people physically handing over their cards to scammers.

The scam starts like many card scams do, with a phone call. Scammers spoof the caller ID of the victim’s bank or credit union, ring them up, and tell them there’s a “problem” with their account. From there, scammers direct victims to cut up their current card—but with a twist. They tell victims to keep the little EMV chip for tap-and-go payments intact.

Why? Victims get instructed to leave the cut-up card and intact chip in the mailbox for a “courier” to pick up for “security purposes.” Once in hand, scammers get access to the bank account associated with the chip. Even if the scammers don’t wrangle a PIN number out of their victims with a little social engineering trickery, they can still make purchases with the chip as some points of sale don’t require a PIN number when tapping to pay.

Here’s how you can avoid the “porch pirate” debit card scam

Shred your old cards in a paper shredder. Then, take the next step. Grab the shredded pieces and throw them away in separate batches. This will all make it fantastically tough for a scammer to piece together your card and steal your info.

Call back your bank yourself. If you get a call, voicemail, or text saying there’s an issue with your account, you can verify any possible issue yourself by calling the number on the back of your card.

Know that banks won’t send “couriers” for cards. And they’ll simply never ask you to leave your card in your mailbox.